01
Why tuotuo mo holds up in the pot
The bread is tuotuo mo (饦饦馍), made “nine parts dead, one part alive” (九死一生): nine parts unleavened dough to one part leavened. That makes it dense enough to hold together in boiling broth. Bakers judge a good one by its golden ring, tiger back and chrysanthemum heart (金圈、虎背、菊花心): a browned rim, a mottled top and a flower-like pattern in the middle. A soft, leavened flatbread would fall apart in the pot.
Each bowl is cooked on its own. Cooks call it 冒 (mào): the torn bread goes into a small pot with a measured ladle of broth and the sliced meat, and boils hard for about two minutes while the cook tosses the pot instead of stirring with a ladle. Glass noodles, green garlic or scallion and cilantro go on top. In Weinan, east of Xi’an, 泡馍 means the water-basin style, broth with bread on the side, and Xi’an’s version is called 煮馍, “cooked bread”—the more accurate name.
The Beijing writer Zhao Heng, who had been to Xi’an four times, most recently in 1993, describes what Tongshengxiang and Lao Sun Jia then took care over. The mutton had to be from plump young sheep; the beef from four-year-old cattle, and only the front half. The meat was boned, then boiled with its bones laid under it, hard at first and then gently, with each shop’s own spices in a cloth bag. When you sat down you were given a big bowl, the bread and a numbered paper slip, and the slip went into the bowl you handed back, so your own torn bread came back to you; he once watched a diner mark his bowl in red pen to test it, and it did. In the kitchen a ladle of old broth was loosened with twice as much water and brought to the boil, the bread, several large pieces of meat, glass noodles and seasoning went in and were turned until soaked through, and a little cured mutton fat finished it. Cilantro, chili paste and sweet pickled garlic came on the side.
Most Xi’an shops sell 牛羊肉泡馍, beef or lamb, and plenty of Xi’an people order beef; lamb usually costs more. The trade grew up in the Hui Muslim quarter that locals call 坊上 (fāngshang). The two names visitors know best are Lao Sun Jia (老孙家), founded in 1898 at the Duanlumen crossing on East Avenue and known for a secret blend of sixteen seasonings, and Tongshengxiang (同盛祥), founded in 1920, whose paomo was served at a state banquet in 1983 and whose beef and lamb paomo technique entered China’s national intangible heritage list in June 2008.
| Explanation | What it says | How far it goes |
|---|---|---|
| The Song emperor | Zhao Kuangyin softened hard bread in mutton soup, and the dish was born. | A folk tale. |
| Old mutton soup | Su Shi, posted to Fengxiang in the early 1060s, wrote that in Qin “the cooking is all mutton soup.” | That was a soup, not torn bread; tracing paomo itself to the Song is legend. |
| Central and West Asia | Bread stewed with mutton and broth is common there, and the name tuotuo mo comes from a word heard as 饦尔木, tuo’ermu. | Put forward by Bai Zhang, a Xi’an scholar of Islamic culture, and managers of the Hui restaurant group Fangshangren; Su Yuhai, who reports it, finds it persuasive but calls it one theory among several. |
Mutton soup has been the food of this region for a long time. Su Shi was a young official in Fengxiang, west of Xi’an, when he wrote that line to his brother on New Year’s Eve; the full couplet runs “in Qin the cooking is all mutton soup, and Long fare has bear jerky” (秦烹惟羊羹,隴饌有熊臘). To an English-language guidebook today it is simply the thing to eat: The Rough Guide to China (2017) calls paomo “the most widely touted Xi’an dish,” notes that locals tear the bread almost to breadcrumbs while foreigners who prefer bigger chunks earn a scornful look, and sends readers to Lao Sun Jia, in business since 1898, and Tongshengxiang.
Take it apart
What’s in a bowl of yangrou paomo
- Torn mo
Tuotuo mo torn small and cooked in the lamb broth
- Lamb
Slices laid over the bread
- Wood ear
Laid over the cooked bread
- Green garlic or scallion
Scattered over at the end
- Sweet pickled garlic
Eaten alongside
02
Tearing the bread
In a traditional shop you pay, collect your bread and a bowl, sit down and tear it yourself. It takes a long time, and nobody hurries you.
Wash your hands first. Break the round in half, then into quarters, then split each quarter through the middle so you are working with thin layers, and pinch off small pieces; it is more pinching than tearing. The old standard is the size of a soybean (黄豆大小). Older people used to call it 蝇子头, “fly heads,” and most now just say soybeans. Young people with good teeth go bigger. Lao Liu Jia (老刘家) has made a newer style popular, 云片 (“cloud slices”): each round split into three layers and torn into about twelve broad pieces, which plenty of lifelong Xi’an residents say they had never seen.
Size matters because the cook has only about two minutes. Big lumps stay white and dry in the middle and do not take up the broth. Small, even pieces are the sign of a regular, and a cook who sees them knows not to cut corners; old cooks were known to push back a bowl they could not work with. If the bread is still white when the bowl arrives, it was not cooked long enough. Properly cooked bread turns faintly yellow from the broth.
Two rounds take a first-timer forty minutes to an hour, and that is part of the meal: people chat while they tear, 边掰边谝 in Shaanxi speech, where 谝 (piǎn) means chatting about nothing in particular. Xi’an grandparents insist on pieces the size of a little fingernail, partly for the flavor and mostly to keep the conversation going. When you are done, hand the bowl back with your number tag and say what you want. Keep your tag: at a busy shop, an hour of tearing can still end with someone else’s bowl.
Almost every shop now also sells machine-cut bread (机器馍). Plenty of locals always use it and say they cannot be bothered to tear; others insist hand-torn bread takes up the broth better. Machine-cut bread is the quick choice for visitors, and the result is consistent.
Small pieces in the bowl
Our own photograph of another bowl of paomo.
Sources [8]
03
Dry, a mouthful of soup, or a moat
When you hand over the bowl, you tell the cook how much broth you want. These are the names every shop understands.
| Style | What arrives | Good to know |
|---|---|---|
| Ganba 干拔 (also 干泡) | The bread has soaked up nearly all the broth | The richest, and a regulars’ order |
| Koutang 口汤 | One mouthful of broth left at the bottom when you finish | The most common order; many say the last mouthful is the best |
| Shuiweicheng 水围城 | Bread in the middle with broth all round it, like a moat round a city wall | The easiest first bowl |
| Danzou 单走 | Broth and bread served separately | You soak the bread yourself, closer to water-basin lamb |
You can also ask for 肉瘦 (lean meat) or 肉肥 (fattier), and 不要明油 for no extra fat on top. One Xi’an local’s advice for a first bowl is shuiweicheng, lean meat and no extra fat. Paomo looks light and is not: the broth is rich and fatty, and the bread is very filling.
The names were not quite the same thirty years ago. Zhao Heng lists 口汤, one mouthful of broth left at the end; 涝汤, a few mouthfuls left, which is what you got if you said nothing; 水围城, where the bread soaked up the broth first and more was poured round it afterwards; and 干爆, cooked until no broth was left at all and then turned in the ladle with oil, which he found a little greasy and rarely saw ordered. He advised tearing the bread to the size of a corn kernel: a fingernail is too big, and rice-grain size is not necessarily better.
Sources [3]
04
When the bowl arrives
Do not stir it. Xi’an people eat paomo from the edge in, a little at a time, and call it 蚕食, “eating like a silkworm.”
A paomo table
A bowl of paomo and what usually comes with it: sweet garlic and chili paste, a cold dish and a bottle of Bingfeng.
From the edge in 蚕食
Start at the rim and work towards the middle without turning the bowl over. The rest stays hot, and the bread underneath does not go soggy.
The chili paste 辣酱
The red paste on the table is a salty fermented chili paste made for paomo, not the chili oil (油泼辣子) Xi’an puts on everything else. It is there for salt more than heat. Put a little on the spot you are about to eat, and do not stir a spoonful into the bowl.
Sweet garlic, a cold dish, a drink 糖蒜、凉菜、冰峰
A bite of paomo, then a clove of sweet pickled garlic to cut the fat. Many people add a cold-dish platter (凉菜拼盘); lotus root dressed sweet and sour (凉拌莲藕) is a common choice and very refreshing. To drink, a bottle of Bingfeng, Xi’an’s orange soda, or sour plum drink (酸梅汤).
Go early for the first broth 头汤
The first broth of the day, 头汤, is the richest. Old shops open around five or six in the morning, and the room fills with older regulars tearing bread. Many good shops sell out and close by two or three in the afternoon, with no dinner service.
05
Where locals eat it
Xi’an people have a rhyme for it: 坊上老刘家,坊外老黄家—Lao Liu Jia inside the Hui quarter, Lao Huang Jia outside it.
Lao Liu Jia 老刘家
On North Guangji Street in the Hui quarter, and the name that comes up most when locals are asked. Several shops share the name, and regulars point people to the North Guangji Street one. The early-morning first broth draws a queue of older locals, the bowls are steady, and a local saying gives it the best broth: 老刘家的汤,老米家的肉, “Lao Liu Jia’s broth, Lao Mi Jia’s meat.”
Guoyuanzhai Lao Mi Jia 果渊斋老米家
On the same street, and the other half of that saying. There are many shops called Lao Mi Jia, and locals joke that only the Guoyuanzhai one counts.
Lao Huang Jia 老黄家
The name outside the quarter, with several branches. Avoid mealtimes unless you are ready to queue.
Other names locals give 本地人还会提
Ma Hong (马洪), where people queue early; Tie Laoshi (铁老十); Chongde Lou (崇德楼), where the diners are almost all locals; and Yizhen Lou (一真楼). Every list gets argued over.
The old brands 老孙家、同盛祥
Lao Sun Jia and Tongshengxiang are the names on visitors’ itineraries, with comfortable dining rooms and a milder, less oily bowl. Locals rarely send people there.
Finding your own 自己找店
Skip the main tourist strip of Muslim Street (回民街). The local rule: a paomo shop still full at two in the afternoon is safe to walk into. Sajinqiao used to be where locals sent people; many now say it has gone the way of the tourist strip.
Price 价钱
At a neighborhood shop, beef paomo costs about ¥22–26 and lamb about ¥26–32. 优质, “premium,” means more meat, sometimes with wood ear and daylily, and runs ¥35–40 at the best-known shops; a shop nearly a century old charged ¥38 for its bowl in 2023.
06
Other bowls called paomo
Xi’an has several bread-in-soup dishes, and the word paomo means different things in neighboring cities.
| Dish | Bread | How it differs |
|---|---|---|
| Stir-fried paomo 小炒泡馍 | Torn tuotuo mo | Cooked in a wok with raw or cooked beef and plenty of vinegar and chili until almost dry; ask for 生熟两搅 to get both kinds of meat |
| Hulutou paomo 葫芦头泡馍 | A partly leavened bread, torn bigger | Pork intestine in a rich broth, sold in non-halal shops |
| Water-basin lamb 水盆羊肉 | A flatbread on the side | Clear lamb soup, with the bread eaten alongside or torn in; what Weinan calls paomo |
| Yuncheng lamb soup 运城羊肉泡 | Ready-baked bread soaked in the soup | From southern Shanxi, including Xia County: lamb bone soup with tofu and lamb blood, often with half a raw onion; locals now say 羊肉泡 to tell it from Xi’an’s |
In Xi’an, paomo on its own means the beef or lamb bowl. Visitors who find it too rich often prefer stir-fried paomo, which is sour and spicy, or the lighter water-basin lamb.
07
More to eat in Xi’an
Xi’an’s other staples built around bread.
Hulatang
The Hui quarter’s breakfast soup: beef meatballs and vegetables in a thick, peppery broth, eaten with bread.
Read the hulatang guide →Roujiamo
Chopped braised meat in a crisp flatbread, the city’s other everyday bread-and-meat meal.
Read the roujiamo guide →FAQ
Questions about Yangrou Paomo
What is paomo?
Bread in soup: 泡 means to soak and 馍 is flatbread. Yangrou paomo is the lamb version from Xi’an, with dense tuotuo mo torn by hand and cooked to order in lamb broth. Yangrou simply means lamb or mutton.
Where is yangrou paomo from?
Xi’an, in Shaanxi. It grew up in the city’s Hui Muslim quarter, and most Xi’an shops sell both beef and lamb versions.
Do you have to tear the bread yourself?
In traditional shops you tear it yourself, into pieces about the size of a soybean. Almost every shop also sells machine-cut bread if you would rather not.
What do ganba, koutang and shuiweicheng mean?
They say how much broth you want: ganba almost none, koutang a mouthful left at the end, shuiweicheng plenty of broth around the bread. Danzou means broth and bread served separately.
Should I order beef or lamb paomo?
Either. Plenty of Xi’an people order beef, and lamb usually costs a little more.
Is Xia County (Yuncheng) lamb paomo the same as Xi’an’s?
No. In Yuncheng, Shanxi, ready-baked bread is soaked in lamb bone soup with tofu and lamb blood, and locals now call it 羊肉泡. In Xi’an the bread is cooked in the broth.
Sources
Sources and further reading
- 1 Reply to Ziyou’s New Year’s Eve poem (和子由除日見寄): “in Qin the cooking is all mutton soup” (in Chinese)Su Shi (Northern Song), on Wikisource ↗
- 2 The Rough Guide to China, pp. 205–207: paomo, tearing the bread, Lao Sun Jia and TongshengxiangRough Guides, London (2017)
- 3 Zhao Heng, “Xi’an thick rice wine and paomo” (西安稠酒与泡馍), in Li Chunmei and Liu Jia (eds.), A Bite of China: A Journey through Chinese Food (舌尖上的中国:中华美食魅力之旅), pp. 246–247 (in Chinese)China Overseas Chinese Publishing House, Beijing (2015)
- 4 Su Yuhai and Cheng Peng, Shaanren Shaancai (陕人陕菜), essay “Legends of yangrou paomo” (羊肉泡的传说) (in Chinese)Northwest University Press, Xi’an (2018)
- 5 Tongshengxiang beef and lamb paomo technique, national intangible heritage list (2008) (in Chinese)China Intangible Cultural Heritage Network ↗
- 6 Time-honored brands in Xi’an: Lao Sun Jia (1898) and Tongshengxiang (1920)China Daily (2025) ↗
- 7 A Xi’an paomo cook of 35 years on serving styles and how the bread is cooked (video, in Chinese)Huiminjie de Ajiaxi (回民街的阿加西), Bilibili ↗
- 8 A Xi’an paomo shop that opens at 5 a.m., and how long it takes to tear the bread (video, in Chinese)Huiminjie de Ajiaxi (回民街的阿加西), Bilibili ↗
- 9 Stir-fried paomo with plenty of vinegar and chili (video, in Chinese)Jun Zai Xi’an (君在西安), Bilibili ↗
- 10 Which Xi’an paomo shop is best? (video, in Chinese)Shenti Luopan (身体罗盘), Bilibili ↗
- 11 A ¥38 bowl of lamb paomo from a shop nearly a century old (video, in Chinese)Dan Niu Shi Zou Qi (丹牛食走起), Bilibili ↗
Last updated November 2026